The announcement made by Minister of Internal Affairs Allan Highet established a significant moment in New Zealand’s national identity. The selection of 'God Save the Queen' as a national anthem alongside 'God Defend New Zealand' illustrated New Zealand's complex relationship with its colonial past and its aspirations toward an independent future. 'God Defend New Zealand,' written in the 1870s, had become increasingly popular and was viewed as emblematic of the unique cultural identity New Zealanders were cultivating. Highet's declaration served not only to affirm the traditional anthem's place but also to simultaneously elevate a homegrown composition that resonated with the people.

The decision reflected the changing attitudes and sentiments of New Zealanders during this period, who were increasingly valuing their distinct identity amid a landscape that had historically favored British traditions. This was part of a broader movement towards recognizing and embracing New Zealand's uniqueness, which would later influence various aspects of New Zealand society, including the arts, education, and politics. The fact that both anthems were recognized highlighted an important acknowledgment of New Zealand's dual heritage, and set a precedent for future discussions about national symbols and patriotism.

It’s noteworthy that this announcement came during a political climate in which the questions of identity and sovereignty were becoming increasingly prominent. As New Zealand navigated its place in the South Pacific, the dual anthem approach allowed for both the preservation of traditional ties and the celebration of a distinctly New Zealand ethos. Over the subsequent decades, this would continue to evolve as the nation further distanced itself from colonial influences and sought to define its own path forward.