The clash on the gridiron between the Massillon Tigers and the Canton Bulldogs culminated in a closely contested match that ended with the Tigers triumphing, 13 to 6. This victory marked a significant milestone as it crowned the Massillon Tigers the champions of the Ohio League, then one of the leading football leagues in the United States. However, what could have been a celebration quickly turned sour as allegations of match-fixing emerged. Eyewitness accounts and criticism from fans hinted that the outcome may have been predetermined, raising serious concerns about the integrity of the game. Accusations fluttered around the state, with rival factions and spectators suggesting that players may not have played to their full capabilities, potentially orchestrated by influences beyond the field.

The scandal not only impacted the Massillon Tigers and Canton Bulldogs but also cast a long shadow over the future of professional football in America. It ignited discussions about the need for regulation and fair play in a sport that was already gaining popularity in the early 20th century. The controversy over the legitimacy of the game's results led to increased scrutiny on professional athletics and prompted calls for reforms aimed at increasing transparency and accountability in sports competitions.

In the backdrop of a rapidly professionalizing world of American sports, the event served as a warning sign against the potential corruption that can arise when money and fame intertwine with athletic competition. As the dust settled, it became apparent that the wrestling match between the two teams would echo through time, prompting future sports authorities to take the issue of match-fixing seriously in order to protect the integrity of all sports.