Garibaldi's Defeat at the Battle of Mentana
Giuseppe Garibaldi led a group of Italian volunteers in an attempt to capture Rome and end the Pope's temporal power. However, they were met with strong opposition from papal forces and French troops at the Battle of Mentana. The engagement resulted in a decisive defeat for Garibaldi and his followers, halting their advance toward Rome and reasserting the Pope's authority in the region.
Garibaldi led 5,000 volunteers at Mentana.
Papal forces were backed by French troops.
The battle halted his campaign for Rome.
Garibaldi's failure delayed Italian unification.
What Happened?
The Battle of Mentana unfolded in the context of the Italian unification movement known as the Risorgimento, where various nationalist leaders sought to unite Italy under a single government. Giuseppe Garibaldi, an iconic figure of this movement, aimed to capture Rome and eliminate the Papal States, which were seen as obstacles to Italian unity. In 1867, Garibaldi's ambition led to a campaign to seize control of Rome, which was still under the rule of Pope Pius IX and supported by French military protection. As Garibaldi and his force of about 5,000 men approached Mentana, they encountered approximately 7,000 papal soldiers reinforced by French troops commanded by General de Failly.
The battle commenced on November 3, where Garibaldi's troops attempted to outmaneuver the papal forces. Despite their initial attempts to engage, the poorly organized Italian volunteers faced intense artillery fire and well-coordinated assaults from the papal army. The French intervention proved significant, bolstering Papal forces and resulting in Garibaldi's forces being decisively overwhelmed. After several hours of combat, Garibaldi's men were forced to retreat, suffering significant casualties and ultimately failing to secure Rome. Following this defeat, Garibaldi’s aspirations for an immediate Italian Republic were severely diminished, although the goal of unifying Italy would ultimately be achieved a few years later in 1870, when the Papal States were annexed.
Why Does it Matter?
The Battle of Mentana is significant for illustrating the tensions between nationalist movements and established authority during the Italian unification process. Garibaldi’s defeat not only demonstrated the limitations of volunteer militias in direct confrontation with regular armies but also highlighted the division between Italian nationalists and the Papal States. The event marked a critical point in the ongoing struggle for unification, foreshadowing the eventual dissolution of papal temporal power and the consolidation of Italy in the years to follow.