The first match played under standardized rules marked a pivotal moment in the evolution of football, with Sheffield F.C. facing Hallam F.C. in Sheffield, England. This specific fixture, deeply rooted in the local culture, is recognized as the oldest existing football rivalry and is a testament to the early organization of football clubs in England. Sheffield F.C. was one of the founding clubs of the Sheffield Rules, a code established in 1857 that would later influence the broader game of association football. This match represented a significant moment in both clubs' histories, showcasing the transition from informal matches to more organized and rule-governed gameplay.

Sheffield F.C. emerged victorious, winning 2-0 in a match that was laden with importance for both teams and the evolution of the sport itself. Notably, the game took place on Boxing Day, a day traditionally associated with festive activities in England, making it an appealing time for local spectators. This contest laid the groundwork for what would become a long-standing animosity and competitive spirit between the two clubs. In the years that followed, the rivalry would ignite tensions on the pitch, culminating in numerous encounters that have etched their place in football folklore.

The fixture has continued annually, with both clubs expressing pride in their shared heritage and contributions to the sport. The match has evolved, incorporating different rule sets and styles of play reflective of broader changes in football. Over the years, it has become not just a sporting event, but a community celebration, drawing supporters and their families to engage in the long-standing tradition formed through teamwork and rivalry.