Supreme Court Limits NLRB Authority in Strikes
February 27th, 1939
February 27th, 1939

How Long Ago?
86 years, 16 days ago
Location
Washington, D.C., United States
Category
Crime & Law
People
- Frank Murphy
- Hugo Black
- William O. Douglas
- Felix Frankfurter
Links & References
- United States labor law
- NLRB v. Fansteel Metallurgical Corp.
- National Labor Relations Board
- Sitdown strike
Tags
Supreme Court Limits NLRB Authority in Strikes
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) lacks the authority to compel employers to rehire workers who participated in sit-down strikes. This ruling arose from the case NLRB v. Fansteel Metallurgical Corp., where the Supreme Court assessed the legality of the sit-down strike tactic. The decision was pivotal, clarifying the boundaries of labor rights and the NLRB's enforcement capabilities.
Case centered on sit-down strike legality
NLRB ruled against for employer rehiring
Limited NLRB's authority over labor disputes
Significant for labor relations history
What Happened?
In NLRB v. Fansteel Metallurgical Corp., the U.S. Supreme Court deliberated on a fundamental question regarding the National Labor Relations Board's (NLRB) jurisdiction concerning employer-employee relations in the context of labor strikes. The case stemmed from an incident at Fansteel Metallurgical, where workers engaged in a sit-down strike — a tactic that had gained traction in union organizing due to its effectiveness in interrupting production without leaving the workplace. The NLRB argued that it had the authority to reinstate the laid-off workers, as the strikes were deemed an exercise of their labor rights under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA).The Court ultimately ruled against the NLRB, determining that the Board did not possess the power to mandate the re-hiring of employees who participated in such strikes. This judgment was rooted in the Court's interpretation of the NLRA and labor law at the time, emphasizing that while the law protected workers' rights to organize and engage in collective bargaining, it did not extend to enforcing their immediate reinstatement if they had been terminated for participating in unlawful strikes. The ruling was significant as it not only limited the NLRB's enforcement capabilities but also set a precedent regarding the legality of certain strike actions within labor relations, shaping the dynamics between labor unions and employers in the years that followed.
Why Does it Matter?
The decision in NLRB v. Fansteel Metallurgical Corp. is notable for its long-lasting implications for labor rights and the regulatory scope of the NLRB. By curtailing the Board's authority, the ruling reflected the judiciary's cautious approach to labor activism and employer interests during a time marked by economic recovery from the Great Depression. This case reinforced the boundaries of permissible strike activities, contributing to the evolution of labor law in America and influencing labor-management negotiations. It illustrates a crucial moment in the interplay between worker rights and employer protections, still relevant in contemporary labor discussions.
Discover More Historic Events from February 27th
JF-17 Thunder Captures Indian Pilot in Dogfight
During an aerial engagement in Jammu and Kashmir, a Pakistan Air Force JF-17 Thunder aircraft engaged and shot down an Indian MiG-21 flown by Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman. Following the aerial combat, which was part of heightened tensions between India and Pakistan, Varthaman was captured and taken into custody by Pakistani forces. The incident highlighted the escalation of military confrontations in the region and received significant media attention worldwide.
Continue ReadingBoris Nemtsov Assassinated in Moscow
Russian politician Boris Nemtsov was shot and killed while walking with his girlfriend in Moscow. He was a prominent critic of President Vladimir Putin and had recently spoken out against the Russian government's actions in Ukraine. The assassination took place near the Kremlin, raising concerns about political violence in Russia. As a public figure who opposed the regime, Nemtsov's murder shocked both locals and international observers.
Continue ReadingDeadly Shooting at Menznau Factory
A shooting at a factory in Menznau, Switzerland, resulted in the deaths of five individuals, including the attacker. The incident occurred during working hours, shocking the local community and prompting discussions on workplace safety and gun control in Switzerland. Witnesses described scenes of chaos and fear as the event unfolded, leading to injuries for five others who were present. The perpetrator, identified later, reportedly had a personal motive connected to workplace grievances.
Continue ReadingMassive Earthquake and Tsunami Strike Chile
An earthquake measuring 8.8 on the moment magnitude scale struck central Chile. The quake caused significant destruction, leaving over 500 dead and thousands injured. It also triggered a tsunami that hit Hawaii shortly after, causing additional concern and emergency responses. This natural disaster affected various regions and resulted in widespread evacuations and humanitarian efforts.
Continue ReadingMas Selamat Kastari's Escape from Detention
Mas Selamat Kastari, a member of Jemaah Islamiyah, escaped from a detention center in Singapore and eluded authorities by hiding in Johor, Malaysia, for over a year. His escape raised significant security concerns in the region and highlighted vulnerabilities in counter-terrorism measures. After extensive manhunts, he was recaptured in April of the following year 2009.
Continue ReadingShanghai Stock Exchange Sees Historic Drop
The Shanghai Stock Exchange witnessed a significant drop of 9%, marking its largest single-day decline in a decade. This sharp decrease was triggered by widespread speculation regarding potential government crackdowns on illicit share offerings and trading practices. Investors reacted fearfully to the prospect of tightening regulations, coupled with growing concerns about rising inflation in China, which exacerbated market uncertainty. The event sent shockwaves through the financial community, illustrating the fragile state of the Chinese stock market.
Continue Reading