Prince Charles Critiques National Gallery Extension
May 17th, 1984
May 17th, 1984

How Long Ago?
40 years, 9 months, 26 days ago
Location
London, England
Category
Arts & Culture
People
- Prince Charles
- Ahrends Burton and Koralek
Links & References
Tags
Prince Charles Critiques National Gallery Extension
Prince Charles publicly criticized the proposed extension to the National Gallery in London, calling it a 'monstrous carbuncle on the face of a much-loved and elegant friend.' This remark sparked a significant debate on the role of the Royal Family in architectural discourse and modern design. The proposed addition aimed to enhance the gallery's infrastructure but faced resistance from various architects and the public. The phrase used by Charles quickly entered popular culture, symbolizing the tensions between tradition and modernity in British architecture.
Prince Charles criticized proposed gallery extension
Referred to design as 'monstrous carbuncle'
Debate sparked on architecture and royal influence
Tensions between modernism and tradition highlighted
What Happened?
During a speech at the Royal Institute of British Architects in 1984, Prince Charles expressed his vehement opposition to a proposed extension of the National Gallery in London. He characterized the design proposed by architect Ahrends Burton and Koralek as a 'monstrous carbuncle on the face of a much-loved and elegant friend.' His comments reflected a broader concern regarding the integration of contemporary architecture within the historic fabric of London, a city known for its treasured heritage and architectural elegance. By referring to the design as a 'monstrous carbuncle,' Charles aimed to emphasize the perceived discord between the old and the new, showcasing his support for preserving historical aesthetics in urban settings.
The public reaction to Prince Charles' condemnation was immediate and polarized. Many people echoed his sentiments, arguing for the importance of maintaining London’s visual character, while others criticized him for overstepping his bounds as a royal figure. Architects and urban planners expressed concern that the Prince’s remarks might influence future building legislation and design approvals, fearing that such criticism could stifle innovation and modernization in architecture. The controversy also raised questions about the responsibilities and influence of the Royal Family in cultural and civic matters in Britain.
This episode in architectural discourse highlighted the ongoing tension between modernist design philosophies and traditional aesthetics. Despite the design eventually being approved, the phrase 'monstrous carbuncle' resonated beyond this instance, becoming synonymous with public critique of new architectural proposals that are seen to clash with established historical contexts. The discourse surrounding the National Gallery addition was reflective not only of architecture but also of broader societal attitudes toward change and preservation, which continue to evolve with urban development.
Why Does it Matter?
This incident serves as a pivotal moment in the conversation surrounding architectural integrity in historic cities. It underlines the significance of public opinion—especially from influential figures like the Prince of Wales—on the urban landscape. The debate initiated by Charles' comments continues to evoke discussions about how contemporary architecture should coexist with historical structures, influencing policy and public sentiment toward modern developments in London and beyond.
Discover More Historic Events from May 17th
Military Plane Crash Kills 17 in Northern Laos
A military aircraft crash in northern Laos resulted in the deaths of 17 individuals. The incident took place during a routine flight in a mountainous region, which is known for challenging flying conditions. Authorities stated that the plane encountered difficulties shortly after takeoff from an airbase, leading to its unfortunate descent. Local emergency services and military personnel were deployed to the site to investigate the cause and assist with recovery efforts.
Continue ReadingPamir Airways Flight 112 Crashes in Afghanistan
Pamir Airways Flight 112, a domestic passenger flight, crashed in the Shakardara District of Afghanistan, resulting in the deaths of all 44 individuals onboard. The flight was en route from Kabul to the northern city of Mazar-i-Sharif when it encountered problems shortly after takeoff. The aircraft went down in rugged terrain, leading to an immediate response from rescue teams and local authorities.
Continue ReadingHistoric Train Test-Run Across the DMZ
Trains from North and South Korea crossed the 38th Parallel in a significant test-run agreement between both governments. This marked a historic moment as it was the first occasion in over 50 years that trains traversed the Demilitarized Zone (DMZ), symbolizing a step towards potential reconciliation and increased cooperation between the two nations. The test involved a train journey starting from the North Korean city of Pyongyang, traveling to the South Korean city of Busan. The event was witnessed by officials from both sides, signaling hopes for improved inter-Korean relations.
Continue ReadingUSS Oriskany Sunk to Create Artificial Reef
The aircraft carrier USS Oriskany was sunk in the Gulf of Mexico to serve as an artificial reef, enhancing marine life while also functioning as a dive site for enthusiasts. This decommissioned vessel was intentionally sunk to promote marine biodiversity, provide recreational diving opportunities, and support local fishing industries. The sinking took place approximately 22 miles off the coast of Pensacola, Florida, and involved careful planning and environmental assessments to ensure safety and minimal environmental impact.
Continue ReadingFirst Legal Same-Sex Marriages in the U.S.
Same-sex marriages officially begin in Massachusetts, marking a significant milestone in LGBTQ+ rights. Celebrations ignite as couples gather to exchange vows, supported by family and friends. The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court's 2003 ruling paved the way, allowing implementation starting on this day. This groundbreaking moment sets a tone for future legal battles across the nation.
Continue ReadingArsenal and Galatasaray Fans Clash in Copenhagen
Violent clashes erupted between Arsenal and Galatasaray fans in Copenhagen during the UEFA Cup Final. The incident involved fighting in the streets and led to numerous injuries and arrests. The match, held at Parken Stadium, was attended by thousands of fans, and the tension between rival supporters escalated before, during, and after the game, resulting in a significant police response. The unrest highlighted ongoing issues with fan violence in football.
Continue Reading