Supreme Court Declares NIRA Unconstitutional
May 27th, 1935
May 27th, 1935

How Long Ago?
89 years, 9 months, 16 days ago
Location
Washington D.C., United States
Category
Politics & Government
People
- Franklin D. Roosevelt
- A.L.A. Schechter
- Supreme Court Justices
Links & References
- Supreme Court of the United States
- National Industrial Recovery Act of 1933
- A.L.A. Schechter Poultry Corp. v. United States
Tags
Supreme Court Declares NIRA Unconstitutional
In A.L.A. Schechter Poultry Corp. v. United States, the Supreme Court ruled that the National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA) was unconstitutional. This ruling arose from a challenge by the Schechter Poultry Corporation, which argued that the federal government overstepped its powers. The decision was significant in curtailing the federal government's ability to regulate industries and set minimum wages or maximum hours within local businesses, impacting the New Deal's economic recovery strategies.
NIRA aimed to regulate industrial recovery
Schechter Poultry challenged federal code enforcement
Supreme Court ruled against federal overreach
Decision limited Congress's regulatory powers
What Happened?
The Supreme Court case of A.L.A. Schechter Poultry Corp. v. United States addressed pivotal questions regarding federal powers in economic regulation during the Great Depression. The Schechter Poultry Corporation, a New York-based business, was accused of violating the National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA), which aimed to stimulate economic recovery by allowing industries to create their own regulations and codes. However, Schechter argued that these codes were unconstitutional as they infringed on the states' rights and the separation of powers framework enshrined in the Constitution. The legal battle escalated to the Supreme Court, where the justices debated the extensive reach of NIRA.Ultimately, the Court unanimously ruled against the federal government, stating that NIRA exceeded the authority granted to Congress under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution. The ruling found that the law improperly delegated legislative powers to the executive branch, thus violating the principle of separation of powers. This landmark decision marked a significant blow to President Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal program, as it reflected growing judicial resistance to expansive federal economic intervention. The ruling raised questions about the legitimacy and limitations of federal authority, prompting reactions that varied from support among conservatives, who viewed the decision as a triumph of constitutionalism, to criticism from those who believed it stifled necessary government action during a period of economic crisis.
Why Does it Matter?
The ruling in A.L.A. Schechter Poultry Corp. v. United States is an interesting case study in constitutional law and the limits of federal power during the New Deal era. It effectively curbed the ability of the federal government to regulate industry and labor, setting a precedent for future judicial interpretations of the Commerce Clause. This case underscored the complexities faced by Roosevelt's administration in implementing recovery measures as the country grappled with the economic fallout of the Great Depression. It highlighted tensions between federal authority and states' rights, a theme that would resonate throughout American legal and political discourse in the decades to follow.
Discover More Historic Events from May 27th
Severe Flooding in Ellicott City, Maryland
A significant flood swept through the Patapsco Valley, resulting in one fatality and catastrophic damage to the first floors of buildings along Main Street in Ellicott City. The flooding caused vehicles to overturn and brought forth emergency response efforts. The intense rainfall leading to this flood overwhelmed local drainage systems, demonstrating the vulnerability of the area to extreme weather. Residents were evacuated as water levels rapidly rose, emphasizing the community's need for improved flood mitigation strategies.
Continue ReadingAndrew Scheer becomes leader of Conservative Party
Andrew Scheer was elected as the leader of the Conservative Party of Canada, succeeding Rona Ambrose. The election took place during a leadership race at the Toronto Congress Centre, where Scheer won over several candidates. His victory marked a significant moment for the Conservative party, transitioning from Ambrose's leadership after an interim period following the resignation of Stephen Harper.
Continue ReadingObama's Historic Visit to Hiroshima
Barack Obama became the first sitting U.S. president to visit Hiroshima Peace Memorial Park, paying tribute to the victims of the atomic bombing during World War II. During this visit, he participated in a ceremony to honor the deceased and met with Hibakusha, survivors of the bomb. His presence underscored a message of reconciliation and a commitment to a world free of nuclear weapons.
Continue ReadingDevastating Yogyakarta Earthquake Hits Central Java
A significant earthquake measuring 6.4 Mw struck Yogyakarta, Indonesia, causing severe destruction and loss of life. The quake, occurring in the early hours, generated an MSK intensity of VIII, classified as damaging. In its aftermath, more than 5,700 people lost their lives, and around 37,000 were reported injured. The event drawn both local and international attention, prompting rescue and relief efforts to the region, thereby highlighting the vulnerability of densely populated areas to seismic activities.
Continue ReadingAbu Sayyaf Group Takes Hostages in Palawan
Members of the Abu Sayyaf group abducted twenty individuals from a luxurious island resort on Palawan, Philippines. The kidnapping occurred during a violent raid aimed at capturing wealthy tourists and locals. The ordeal lasted for over a year, with significant repercussions for Philippine security forces and regional tourism.
Continue ReadingFirst Shuttle Mission to Dock with ISS
Space Shuttle Discovery launched on STS-96, marking the first shuttle mission to dock with the International Space Station (ISS). This mission aimed to demonstrate the capabilities of the shuttle during the process of docking and delivery of supplies and equipment needed for assembling the ISS. The crew included veteran astronaut Charles D. Gemar and mission specialist Julie A. Payette, who represented the Canadian Space Agency. The successful docking furthered international collaboration in space exploration.
Continue Reading