Supreme Court Rules Against Military Tribunals
June 29th, 2006
June 29th, 2006

How Long Ago?
18 years, 8 months, 15 days ago
Location
Washington D.C., United States
Category
Crime & Law
People
- John Roberts
- Ruth Bader Ginsburg
- Donald Rumsfeld
- Salim Ahmed Hamdan
Links & References
- Supreme Court of the United States
- George W. Bush
- Guantanamo Bay detention camp
- Hamdan v. Rumsfeld
- International law
Tags
Supreme Court Rules Against Military Tribunals
The U.S. Supreme Court delivered a landmark decision involving the legality of military commissions set up by the Bush administration to try detainees at Guantanamo Bay. The court ruled that these military tribunals violated both the Uniform Code of Military Justice and the Geneva Conventions, thus asserting the requirement for fair trial rights and adherence to established legal frameworks. The case centered around the detainee Salim Ahmed Hamdan, who was captured in Afghanistan and designated as an enemy combatant. The ruling underscored the tension between national security measures and civil liberties.
Court ruled military tribunals unconstitutional
Case involved Salim Ahmed Hamdan as a detainee
Ruling emphasized due process for all detainees
Decision limited presidential powers in war
What Happened?
The case of Hamdan v. Rumsfeld arose from Salim Ahmed Hamdan's detention at Guantanamo Bay, where he was being held as an alleged enemy combatant. The Bush administration had established military commissions to try detainees, asserting that these commissions were necessary for national security. Hamdan challenged the legality of the military tribunals, arguing they violated U.S. laws and international treaties governing the treatment of prisoners. The issues at stake included the rights of detainees, the definition of lawful combat, and the extent of presidential power in wartime. The Supreme Court heard the case, resulting in a 5-3 decision. Chief Justice John Roberts recused himself, while Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, along with her colleagues, emphasized the importance of rules established by both U.S. law and international conventions. The Court concluded that the military commissions were unconstitutional because they deviated from the established military justice system outlined in the Uniform Code of Military Justice. Furthermore, the Court found that the tribunals did not provide the defendants the necessary protections guaranteed under the Geneva Conventions, which are designed to protect individuals who are not taking a direct part in hostilities.
Why Does it Matter?
The decision in Hamdan v. Rumsfeld is significant as it reaffirmed the principle that all individuals, regardless of their status as enemy combatants, are entitled to due process and protections under both U.S. law and international conventions. This ruling set a precedent that limited executive power in times of war and highlighted the importance of maintaining constitutional protections even in the face of national security concerns. It contributed to ongoing debates about civil liberties in the context of terrorism and military action.
Discover More Historic Events from June 29th
Islamic State Declares Caliphate in Iraq and Syria
The Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, commonly known as ISIS, proclaimed a caliphate extending across parts of Syria and northern Iraq. This announcement was made by the group's leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, during a sermon at the Grand Mosque in Mosul. This unification of territories under a caliphate structure was aimed at establishing a new Islamic governance system, directly challenging existing states in the region. The declaration signified a pivotal moment in the ongoing conflict in the Middle East, highlighting the aspirations of ISIS to create a dominant, self-styled Islamic state.
Continue ReadingDerecho Causes Widespread Damage in Eastern U.S.
A derecho swept across the eastern United States, wreaking havoc with damaging winds exceeding 80 mph, affecting states from Ohio to Virginia. The storm resulted in at least 22 fatalities and left millions without power, with the hardest-hit areas including West Virginia and Maryland. The high winds uprooted trees, destroyed buildings, and knocked out power lines, prompting emergency declarations in multiple states. The storm traveled over 700 miles in just a few hours, showcasing the intense and rapid nature of the weather phenomenon.
Continue ReadingFirst Release of Apple's iPhone
Apple Inc. launched its first mobile phone, the iPhone, revolutionizing the smartphone market with its sleek design and innovative touchscreen interface. This highly anticipated device was unveiled by CEO Steve Jobs during a keynote address in January and saw its official release in the United States. The iPhone combined an iPod, a phone, and an internet communicator, changing how people interacted with technology, leading to widespread adoption of smartphones around the world.
Continue ReadingNaval Clash Results in Sailor Casualties
A naval skirmish occurred between South Korean and North Korean forces in the Yellow Sea, resulting in the death of six South Korean sailors. The clash led to the sinking of a North Korean vessel. Tensions between the two Koreas had been escalating, leading to this head-on confrontation. The incident is notable for highlighting ongoing military confrontations in a region still divided by political and territorial disputes. South Korea claimed that the incident was an act of aggression, while North Korea asserted their actions were defensive.
Continue ReadingFirst Docking of Atlantis with Mir Space Station
Space Shuttle Atlantis successfully docked with the Russian space station Mir, marking a significant milestone in international space cooperation. This historic moment took place during NASA's STS-71 mission, which began a new era in human spaceflight by establishing a direct link between U.S. and Russian space efforts. The crew facilitated experiments and technology exchanges aboard Mir, showcasing collaborative achievements in space exploration.
Continue ReadingSampoong Department Store Collapse in Seoul
In Seoul's Seocho District, the Sampoong Department Store collapsed, leading to the deaths of 502 people and injuring 937. The collapse occurred during peak shopping hours, shocking the local community and raising serious questions about building safety standards and regulations in South Korea. The tragedy highlighted deep flaws in the construction practices and oversight that allowed such a structure to exist.
Continue Reading