Supreme Court Establishes Good-Faith Exception
July 5th, 1984
July 5th, 1984
How Long Ago?
40 years, 8 months, 10 days ago
Location
Washington, D.C.
Category
Crime & Law
People
- Harry Blackmun
- Sandra Day O'Connor
- William H. Rehnquist
- Byron White
Links & References
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution
- United States v. Leon
- Good-faith exception
- Exclusionary rule
Tags
Supreme Court Establishes Good-Faith Exception
The United States Supreme Court ruled in United States v. Leon that evidence obtained via a defective search warrant could still be admissible in court if law enforcement officials acted in good faith. The case originated from a narcotics investigation where the warrant lacked probable cause. This ruling introduced the 'good-faith' exception to the Fourth Amendment exclusionary rule, transforming the legal landscape regarding how evidence is treated in criminal trials.
Introduced good-faith exception in law.
Key case for Fourth Amendment applications.
Impact on evidence admissibility in trials.
Reinforced lawful police conduct expectations.
What Happened?
In United States v. Leon, the Supreme Court addressed the applicability of the exclusionary rule, which traditionally barred the admission of evidence in criminal trials if it was obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment. The case involved police officers who executed a search warrant for narcotics on the basis of an affidavit that was later determined to be insufficient to establish probable cause. While the evidence was indeed obtained through a flawed warrant, the Supreme Court ultimately ruled that the officers acted in good faith, believing they were executing a valid warrant. This pivotal decision did not negate the protection against unlawful searches but recognized that excluding relevant evidence due to police error could unduly hamper vigorous prosecution in serious criminal offenses. Thus, the Court carved out a good-faith exception which has had lasting implications for law enforcement practices regarding search and seizure.
Why Does it Matter?
The ruling in United States v. Leon significantly impacted how courts handle the issue of unlawfully obtained evidence. By establishing the good-faith exception, the Supreme Court aimed to strike a balance between protecting individual privacy rights and ensuring that legitimate evidence could be presented in court. This decision has been referenced in numerous cases since, influencing the work of law enforcement and the judiciary in their respective roles within the justice system.
Discover More Historic Events from July 5th
Keir Starmer Becomes Labour Prime Minister
Keir Starmer is appointed Prime Minister by Charles III, making history as the first Labour leader to win a general election since Tony Blair in 2005 and the first Labour Prime Minister since Gordon Brown in 2010. His ascension follows a period of significant political shifts in the UK, reflecting a return to Labour governance. Starmer's leadership brings renewed hope for progressive policies and reforms in various sectors, aiming to address issues such as social justice, economy, and climate change.
Continue ReadingSajid Javid and Rishi Sunak Resign from Cabinet
British government ministers Sajid Javid and Rishi Sunak resigned from their positions in Prime Minister Boris Johnson's cabinet, marking a significant escalation in political turmoil within the United Kingdom. Javid, the Health Secretary, and Sunak, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, both cited concerns over the government's handling of various issues, including integrity and public trust. Their resignations were seen as pivotal moments that triggered a wave of subsequent departures from the Johnson administration.
Continue ReadingJuno Space Probe Begins Its Jupiter Mission
The Juno space probe entered orbit around Jupiter, marking a significant milestone in space exploration. Launched in 2011, Juno's objective is to study the planet's atmosphere, magnetic field, and internal structure. The probe is equipped with advanced scientific instruments to gather data over a 20-month period. This mission aims to improve understanding of the solar system's formation and the gas giant's history, providing invaluable insights into the nature of Jupiter and its role in the solar system.
Continue ReadingThe Shard becomes Europe's tallest building
In London, The Shard was inaugurated as the tallest building in Europe at a height of 310 metres (1,020 ft). Designed by architect Renzo Piano, the structure features a distinctive glass façade and hosts shops, restaurants, and residences alongside office space. The building's opening represented a significant milestone in the regeneration of the London Bridge area and was celebrated for its architectural innovation. The Shard quickly became an iconic symbol of modern London.
Continue ReadingRiots Erupt in Ürümqi Amid Ethnic Tensions
In Ürümqi, violent riots broke out featuring significant unrest between ethnic Han Chinese and Uyghurs. Sparked by misinformation about a violent incident in Guangdong involving Uyghur workers, the demonstrations turned violent as protesters clashed with police. The unrest escalated rapidly, leading to widespread destruction and loss of life. The situation drew national attention as calls for enhanced security and government intervention increased amid grievances over ethnic and cultural discrimination.
Continue ReadingDiscovery of Largest Anglo-Saxon Gold Hoard
Near the village of Hammerwich, Staffordshire, a metal detectorist uncovered the largest hoard of Anglo-Saxon gold ever discovered in Britain, consisting of more than 1,500 items. The find included exquisite jewelry, decorative artifacts, and weapons, dating from the 6th to 8th centuries. The discovery was made by Terry Herbert, who reported the findings to local authorities, leading to an excavation that uncovered treasures of significant historical value and insight into early medieval British culture.
Continue Reading