Margaret Gorman garnered national attention when she triumphed at the inaugural Atlantic City Pageant, held in 1921. At just 16, her enchanting presence and poise captivated judges and onlookers, leading her to clinch the coveted Golden Mermaid trophy. This event was a significant part of a promotional effort to re-establish Atlantic City as a premier summer destination post-World War I. The contest aimed to attract visitors to the coastal city while showcasing young women's beauty and talent. Gorman's victory quickly became iconic as pageant officials anointed her the first Miss America, a title that would endure and evolve over the decades.

The pageant's format emphasized not only physical beauty but also intelligence and talent, elements that later became staples in subsequent competitions. Gorman's win was a turning point, garnering media coverage and public interest that paved the way for the establishment of Miss America as a national symbol of beauty and femininity in America. This prototype of the pageant provided a platform for women to showcase their talents beyond mere aesthetics, leading to a unique intersection of entertainment, culture, and societal expectations. Her reign as Miss America began a tradition that would continue for years, drawing millions of viewers and participants alike.

In the years following, beauty pageants would continue to evolve, creating significant cultural dialogues around femininity, body image, and the roles women play in society. Gorman's landmark victory transformed the perception of pageants from simple contests to celebrated competitions that recognized and honored the multifaceted nature of women.